|
|
Post by Marching Observer on Oct 23, 2021 14:56:00 GMT -6
I dont see Lawrence Township on your list, but the rest were spot on MPLT is short for Marching Pride of Lawrence Township. Sorry for the confusion on that!  |
|
|
|
Post by Jake W. on Oct 23, 2021 15:01:56 GMT -6
I’m pretty happy with all of those results! I didn’t personally have MPLT in, but I’m THRILLED that they get to keep their streak of finals appearances going.
Edgewood winning A was as it should have been in my eyes, and western deservedly won music. Monrovia over Forest Park or Fairfield or Lewis Cass is an interesting one; congrats to them!!
I think the AA rankings are perfect and I’m glad Worthington Kilbourne got recognized. Choctaw was fabulous and deserved to sweep.
Carmel sweeping (well, effectively sweeping) doesn’t surprise me at all. They were great. I had Mason in third as well.
And congrats to Goshen!!!! Topping Franklin in AAA and making what I believe to be their first super regional finals appearance? They’ve made it at Dayton, Toledo, etc but not ever at the big shows, I believe. They put on a terrific show and earned their spot.
I unfortunately am unable to watch tonight, but I really enjoyed watching all of prelims, and I can’t wait to get home tonight and find out the results! Could be some juicy mix ups.
|
|
|
|
Post by hostrauser on Oct 23, 2021 15:38:33 GMT -6
FINALIST BANDS (alphabetical order) Avon H.S., IN Brownsburg H.S., IN Carmel H.S., IN Castle H.S., IN Center Grove H.S., IN Centerville H.S., OH Choctaw H.S., OK Fishers H.S., IN Franklin H.S., TN Goshen H.S., IN Greenwood Community H.S., IN Homestead H.S., IN Owasso H.S., OK William Mason H.S., OH First band out: North Hardin H.S., KY (15th) Second band out: Lawrence Township H.S., IN (16th) I called 13 of 14, and the one I missed was my 2nd band out. Another successful showing for the algorithm.  |
|
|
|
Post by paddy on Oct 23, 2021 15:49:16 GMT -6
At best you are sorting 3 bands on the bubble. Missing 1 of 3 grades at a D.
|
|
|
|
Post by Marching Observer on Oct 23, 2021 16:00:20 GMT -6
At best you are sorting 3 bands on the bubble. Missing 1 of 3 grades at a D. Depends on the school system. I know of some that 70% is still and F...  |
|
|
|
Post by hewhowaits on Oct 23, 2021 16:14:02 GMT -6
At best you are sorting 3 bands on the bubble. Missing 1 of 3 grades at a D. Depends on the school system. I know of some that 70% is still and F... There are some places that 70% will make you the valedictorian. |
|
|
|
Post by musicman12489 on Oct 23, 2021 17:17:21 GMT -6
Did anyone else find that Centerville's show design is quite lacking?
|
|
|
|
Post by hostrauser on Oct 23, 2021 22:08:02 GMT -6
Greenwood in local competition was behind Greenfield by 1.5 points last week same block/same panel. LT was .9 behind Greenfield same panel/same day, but later time. Greenfield was within 8.75 behind Avon same bloc/same panel 2 weeks ago and 9.9 behind Avon same panel/same day, but later time last week. And these were legitimate panels with BOA level judges on them. I know the algorithm is being thrown by their poor showing at Dayton, but recent data suggests that they are in the hunt. INDY PRELIMS 74.650 Greenwood Community H.S., IN 72.450 Greenfield-Central H.S., IN  |
|
|
|
Post by indyfan921 on Oct 23, 2021 22:10:44 GMT -6
The gap between Greenwood and GC to Munster was larger than I expected. There was like a 5 point gap or something.
|
|
|
|
Post by paddy on Oct 23, 2021 22:50:50 GMT -6
Greenwood in local competition was behind Greenfield by 1.5 points last week same block/same panel. LT was .9 behind Greenfield same panel/same day, but later time. Greenfield was within 8.75 behind Avon same bloc/same panel 2 weeks ago and 9.9 behind Avon same panel/same day, but later time last week. And these were legitimate panels with BOA level judges on them. I know the algorithm is being thrown by their poor showing at Dayton, but recent data suggests that they are in the hunt. INDY PRELIMS 74.650 Greenwood Community H.S., IN 72.450 Greenfield-Central H.S., IN Look at the recaps. Greenfield isn’t dropping a 54th place visual score on the regular. Don’t try to convince me your algorithm predicts that. Put a typical score in there for visual and Greenfield is above Greenwood by a comfortable margin. Congratulations on your luck. |
|
|
|
Post by paddy on Oct 23, 2021 23:02:09 GMT -6
Let’s review the finals predictions from the mystical algorithm…
FINALS PREDICTION
89.950 Avon H.S., IN (actual Carmel 91.7)
87.825 Carmel H.S., IN (actual Avon 91.5)
86.175 William Mason H.S., OH (actual WM 88.7)
84.650 Castle H.S., IN (actual Castle 85.7)
83.625 Fishers H.S., IN (Fishers 85.62)
82.450 Homestead H.S., IN (Brownsburg 85.5)
81.150 Brownsburg H.S., IN (homestead 83.75)
80.850 Centerville H.S., OH (actual CG 82.85)
80.750 Owasso H.S., OK (Owasso 82.2)
79.750 Franklin H.S., TN (Centerville 81.55)
77.950 Center Grove H.S., IN ( MPLT 80.7)
76.525 Goshen H.S., IN (Franklin TN 80.57)
75.575 Choctaw H.S., OK (Goshen 80.15)
75.225 Greenwood Community H.S., IN (Choctaw 77.1)
4 placings out of 14
No scores correct
No gaps correct
|
|
|
|
Post by hewhowaits on Oct 25, 2021 5:22:41 GMT -6
Looking at the recaps I noticed Monrovia as a late addition to the schedule. That brought the total number of bands to 64. Had one more band added late, this would have been a two-panel prelims.
|
|
|
|
Post by Allohak on Oct 25, 2021 6:35:10 GMT -6
Looking at the recaps I noticed Monrovia as a late addition to the schedule. That brought the total number of bands to 64. Had one more band added late, this would have been a two-panel prelims. Attendance was capped at 64 to avoid the potential for this change on short notice |
|
|
|
Post by verysaxy on Oct 25, 2021 18:41:03 GMT -6
An interesting note:
Had there been two panels in the traditional 121212 schedule (block one is panel 1, block two is panel 2, block three is panel 1, etc), using the real scores, we notice only one finalist band would’ve missed finals had there been two panels: Goshen, IN.
They would be replaced by Ben Davis, IN.
|
|
|
|
Post by LeanderMomma on Oct 26, 2021 6:47:56 GMT -6
Let’s review the finals predictions from the mystical algorithm… FINALS PREDICTION 89.950 Avon H.S., IN (actual Carmel 91.7) 87.825 Carmel H.S., IN (actual Avon 91.5) 86.175 William Mason H.S., OH (actual WM 88.7) 84.650 Castle H.S., IN (actual Castle 85.7) 83.625 Fishers H.S., IN (Fishers 85.62) 82.450 Homestead H.S., IN (Brownsburg 85.5) 81.150 Brownsburg H.S., IN (homestead 83.75) 80.850 Centerville H.S., OH (actual CG 82.85) 80.750 Owasso H.S., OK (Owasso 82.2) 79.750 Franklin H.S., TN (Centerville 81.55) 77.950 Center Grove H.S., IN ( MPLT 80.7) 76.525 Goshen H.S., IN (Franklin TN 80.57) 75.575 Choctaw H.S., OK (Goshen 80.15) 75.225 Greenwood Community H.S., IN (Choctaw 77.1) 4 placings out of 14 No scores correct No gaps correct I’m starting to think this pesky algorithm is going to start WWIII. |
|
|
|
Post by drummerboy on Oct 26, 2021 21:56:27 GMT -6
Let’s review the finals predictions from the mystical algorithm… FINALS PREDICTION 89.950 Avon H.S., IN (actual Carmel 91.7) 87.825 Carmel H.S., IN (actual Avon 91.5) 86.175 William Mason H.S., OH (actual WM 88.7) 84.650 Castle H.S., IN (actual Castle 85.7) 83.625 Fishers H.S., IN (Fishers 85.62) 82.450 Homestead H.S., IN (Brownsburg 85.5) 81.150 Brownsburg H.S., IN (homestead 83.75) 80.850 Centerville H.S., OH (actual CG 82.85) 80.750 Owasso H.S., OK (Owasso 82.2) 79.750 Franklin H.S., TN (Centerville 81.55) 77.950 Center Grove H.S., IN ( MPLT 80.7) 76.525 Goshen H.S., IN (Franklin TN 80.57) 75.575 Choctaw H.S., OK (Goshen 80.15) 75.225 Greenwood Community H.S., IN (Choctaw 77.1) 4 placings out of 14 No scores correct No gaps correct I’m starting to think this pesky algorithm is going to start WWIII. I won't say I told you so.....but....I did guess, I mean predict Carmel at 91.5+ with Avon right on their heals and that all the scores would be higher. No algorithm was used or harmed in my guessing! lol |
|
|
|
Post by avidmarchingduck on Oct 27, 2021 10:43:14 GMT -6
Does ANYONE think that William Mason might be above Carmel or Avon tonight? I sure do! Personally I loved the fact that they used an oboe as a soloist, such a rare but beautiful suprise! Personally as an oboe player myself I wish I could hear more of this particular player throughout the show perhaps in the ballad? Other than that it was refreshing to see their drill demand more actual marching (rather than choreo) but I do have high hopes for William Mason! |
|
