|
|
Post by ilikeguard on Oct 11, 2022 14:36:25 GMT -6
You've seen the Top 32 Rankings. You've seen the Rankings by State 2022 thread. You've seen both turmoil and an incredibly impressive depth of knowledge in both. So, in the spirit of at least one of those, I'm reviving the concept of Rankings by Class!
I'm looking for primarily BOA bands here, but if there's an argument to be made for a non-BOA band, argue away. I'll start off with what I'm feeling so far out of this year's season, but I hope to see alternative opinions on my rankings. This is your time to tell me I'm wrong! I'll use this week's Top 32 as a basis, and extend from there. I don't know everything, so please correct me (seriously).
AAAA
1. Hebron (TX)
2. Broken Arrow (OK)
3. Carmel (IN)
4. Vandegrift (TX)
5. Avon (IN)
6. Flower Mound (TX)
7. Cedar Ridge (TX)
8. Ronald Reagan (TX)
9. Claudia Taylor Johnson (TX)
10. Marcus (TX)
AAA
1. Dobyns-Bennett (TN)
2. Cedar Park (TX)
3. Blue Springs (MO)
4. Rouse (TX)
5. Wakeland (TX)
6. Castle (IN)
7. Leander (TX)
8. Rosemount (MN)
9. Stephen F. Austin (TX)
10. Clovis (NM)
AA
1. Tarpon Springs (FL)
2. Jenison (MI)
3. Kiski Area (PA)
4. Grain Valley (MO)
5. Choctaw (OK)
6. Franklin (TN)
7. Morton (IL)
8. Camdenton (MO)
9. North Hardin (KY)
10. Evansville North (IN)
A
1. Murray (KY)
2. Archbishop Alter (OH)
3. Bourbon County (KY)
4. Sullivan (MO)
5. MOC-Floyd Valley (IA)
6. Beechwood (KY)
7. Adair County (KY)
8. Independence (IA)
9. Hollister (MO)
10. Sallisaw (OK)
? ? ?
1. Marian Catholic (IL)
|
|
|
|
Post by abtwitch on Oct 11, 2022 15:14:11 GMT -6
I have entered the marketplace of ideas to epically OWN ilikeguard using my two secret weapons: FACTS and LOGIC. Here are the OBJECTIVELY CORRECT and INARGUABLE Class A Rankings and if you DISAGREE I am going to have to ask you to not be CRINGE. 1. Beechwood (KY) 2. Bourbon County (KY) 3. Murray (KY) 4. Canton (TX) 5. Archbishop Alter (OH) 6. Sullivan (MO) 7. Krum (TX) 8. MOC-Floyd Valley (IA) 9. Independence (IA) 10. Hollister (MO) I have studied the ancient art of being TOTALLY and ENTIRELY UNBIASED to put together these rankings. Debate me if you DARE enter the arena. |
|
|
|
Post by ilikeguard on Oct 11, 2022 15:38:25 GMT -6
I have been ratio'd
|
|
|
|
Post by philodemus on Oct 11, 2022 15:39:55 GMT -6
I have entered the marketplace of ideas to epically OWN ilikeguard using my two secret weapons: FACTS and LOGIC. Here are the OBJECTIVELY CORRECT and INARGUABLE Class A Rankings and if you DISAGREE I am going to have to ask you to not be CRINGE. 1. Beechwood (KY) 2. Bourbon County (KY) 3. Murray (KY) 4. Canton (TX) 5. Archbishop Alter (OH) 6. Sullivan (MO) 7. Krum (TX) 8. MOC-Floyd Valley (IA) 9. Independence (IA) 10. Hollister (MO) I have studied the ancient art of being TOTALLY and ENTIRELY UNBIASED to put together these rankings. Debate me if you DARE enter the arena. Three Kentucky bands in the top three spots... Logic checks out! It's a bummer Bourbon isn't headed to Grand Nats. They may well be the best band in our state this season. |
|
|
|
Post by trumpet300 on Oct 12, 2022 6:39:14 GMT -6
You've seen the Top 32 Rankings. You've seen the Rankings by State 2022 thread. You've seen both turmoil and an incredibly impressive depth of knowledge in both. So, in the spirit of at least one of those, I'm reviving the concept of Rankings by Class! I'm looking for primarily BOA bands here, but if there's an argument to be made for a non-BOA band, argue away. I'll start off with what I'm feeling so far out of this year's season, but I hope to see alternative opinions on my rankings. This is your time to tell me I'm wrong! I'll use this week's Top 32 as a basis, and extend from there. I don't know everything, so please correct me (seriously). AAAA 1. Hebron (TX) 2. Broken Arrow (OK) 3. Carmel (IN) 4. Vandegrift (TX) 5. Avon (IN) 6. Flower Mound (TX) 7. Cedar Ridge (TX) 8. Ronald Reagan (TX) 9. Claudia Taylor Johnson (TX) 10. Marcus (TX) AAA 1. Dobyns-Bennett (TN) 2. Cedar Park (TX) 3. Blue Springs (MO) 4. Rouse (TX) 5. Wakeland (TX) 6. Castle (IN) 7. Leander (TX) 8. Rosemount (MN) 9. Stephen F. Austin (TX) 10. Clovis (NM) AA 1. Tarpon Springs (FL) 2. Jenison (MI) 3. Kiski Area (PA) 4. Grain Valley (MO) 5. Choctaw (OK) 6. Franklin (TN) 7. Morton (IL) 8. Camdenton (MO) 9. North Hardin (KY) 10. Evansville North (IN) A 1. Murray (KY) 2. Archbishop Alter (OH) 3. Bourbon County (KY) 4. Sullivan (MO) 5. MOC-Floyd Valley (IA) 6. Beechwood (KY) 7. Adair County (KY) 8. Independence (IA) 9. Hollister (MO) 10. Sallisaw (OK) ? ? ? 1. Marian Catholic (IL) This is sorta how mine would look. AAAA 1. Hebron (TX) 2. Broken Arrow (OK) 3. Vandegrift (TX) 4. Carmel (IN) 5. Avon (IN) 6. Flower Mound (TX) 7. Cedar Ridge (TX) 8. Ronald Reagan (TX) 9. Marcus (TX) 10. Claudia Taylor Johnson (TX) AAA 1. Dobyns-Bennett (TN) 2. Blue Springs (MO) 3. Rouse (TX) 4. Cedar Park (TX) 5. Wakeland (TX) 6. Castle (IN) 7. Leander (TX) 8. Stephen F. Austin (TX) 9. Clovis (NM) 10. Rosemount (MN) AA 1. Tarpon Springs (FL) 2. Norwin (PA) 3. Kiski (PA) 4. Jenison (MI) 5. Grain Valley (MO) 6. Franklin (TN) 7. Choctaw (OK) 8. Morton (IL) 9. Camdenton (MO) 10. North Hardin (KY) ***If Marian is still in 2A which I think they will be, I'd put them in 7 and push everyone down one spot and put North Hardin off the list. A Honestly don't know enough about these bands to make a decision. |
|
|
|
Post by abtwitch on Nov 24, 2022 14:41:43 GMT -6
AA Rankings cause I feel like it today:
1. Tarpon Springs (FL) (obviously)
2. Argyle (TX)
3. Lovejoy (TX)
4. Morton (IL)
5. Kiski Area (PA)
6. Jenison (MI)
7. Roma (TX)
8. Catawba Ridge (SC)
9. Dartmouth (MA)
10. Norwin (PA)
11. Germantown (MS)
12. Hernando (MS)
13. South Jones (MS)
14. Lake Hamilton (AR)
15. Green Canyon (UT)
16. Grain Valley (MO)
17. Franklin (TN)
18. Miamisburg (OH)
19. Campbell County (KY)
20. Jasper (IN)
21. Camdenton (MO)
22. Marian Catholic (IL)
23. Loveland (CO)
24. Anderson County (KY)
25. Reeths-Puffer (MI)
Probably forgot a few obvious ones, but those are my post-season thoughts
|
|
