|
Post by MarchingBand4Life on Oct 19, 2023 22:59:19 GMT -6
1 state representative. 50 bands.
The band does not have to have a history of BOA competition.
Who are your finalist predictions? Semi Finalists?
|
|
|
Post by hewhowaits on Oct 20, 2023 6:13:18 GMT -6
If there are only 50 bands, there won't be a semifinals. But there would be 14 finalists.
|
|
|
Post by coleeich on Oct 20, 2023 6:31:11 GMT -6
Predictions! Grand-Nats-One-Band-Per-State-Representation-Style
1. Hebron H.S., TX 2. Carmel H.S., IN 3. Broken Arrow H.S., OK 4. William Mason H.S., OH 5. Tarpon Springs H.S., FL 6. Blue Springs H.S., MO 7. Dobyns-Bennett H.S., TN 8. Wando H.S., SC 9. American Fork H.S., UT 10. Bentonville H.S., AR 11. Rosemount H.S., MN 12. Lincoln H.S., SD 13. O'Fallon Township H.S., IL 14. Jenison H.S., MI
Made based on the assumption that the top band from each state would represent and that there would be 14 finalists.
|
|
|
Post by philodemus on Oct 20, 2023 7:11:11 GMT -6
Predictions! Grand-Nats-One-Band-Per-State-Representation-Style1. Hebron H.S., TX 2. Carmel H.S., IN 3. Broken Arrow H.S., OK 4. William Mason H.S., OH 5. Tarpon Springs H.S., FL 6. Blue Springs H.S., MO 7. Dobyns-Bennett H.S., TN 8. Wando H.S., SC 9. American Fork H.S., UT 10. Bentonville H.S., AR 11. Rosemount H.S., MN 12. Lincoln H.S., SD 13. O'Fallon Township H.S., IL 14. Jenison H.S., MI Made based on the assumption that the top band from each state would represent and that there would be 14 finalists. There is a severe lack of Bluegrass in this prediction. We might not break top half, but we'd be right there in that bottom half tussle.
|
|
|
Post by MarchingBand4Life on Oct 20, 2023 7:56:51 GMT -6
Predictions! Grand-Nats-One-Band-Per-State-Representation-Style1. Hebron H.S., TX 2. Carmel H.S., IN 3. Broken Arrow H.S., OK 4. William Mason H.S., OH 5. Tarpon Springs H.S., FL 6. Blue Springs H.S., MO 7. Dobyns-Bennett H.S., TN 8. Wando H.S., SC 9. American Fork H.S., UT 10. Bentonville H.S., AR 11. Rosemount H.S., MN 12. Lincoln H.S., SD 13. O'Fallon Township H.S., IL 14. Jenison H.S., MI Made based on the assumption that the top band from each state would represent and that there would be 14 finalists. Pretty much what I was thinking. 1-4, for sure. 5-8 a toss-up within those 4 spots. 9-14, also a toss up, IMO
|
|
|
Post by yayband914 on Oct 20, 2023 12:07:37 GMT -6
This was hard. Dissect and interject at will. I didn't spend TOO much time thinking about rankings so feedback is welcomed. Give or take with a +/- 3-5 placement differential.
Montana, North Dakota, Rhode Island or Vermont do not qualify as they either have no marching band programs, or very few, and if they have any at all, they usually aren't competitive.
1. Hebron H.S., TX 2. Carmel H.S., IN 3. Broken Arrow H.S., OK 4. William Mason H.S., OH 5. Tarpon Springs H.S., FL 6. Blue Springs H.S., MO 7. Wando H.S., SC 8. Bentonville H.S., AR 9. Dobyns-Bennett H.S., TN 10. American Fork H.S., UT 11. O'Fallon Township H.S., IL 12. Ayala H.S., CA 13. Rosemount H.S., MN 14. Lincoln H.S., SD 15. Harrison H.S., GA 16. Lafayette H.S., KY 17. Kiski Area H.S., PA 18. Clovis H.S., NM 19. Jenison H.S., MI 20. Hernando H.S., MS 21. Grants Pass H.S., OR 22. Fossil Ridge H.S., CO 23. Dartmouth H.S., MA 24. James Madison H.S., VA 25. Lafayette H.S., LA 26. Green Level H.S., NC 27. Mountain Ridge H.S., AZ 28. Mililani H.S., HI 29. Millard West H.S., NE 30. Sparkman H.S., AL 31. Foothill H.S., NV 32. Blue Valley H.S., KS 33. John P. Stevens H.S., NJ 34. Cicero-North Syracuse H.S., NY 35. Pella H.S., IA 36. Ridgeline H.S., WA 37. Greendale H.S., WI 38. Trumbull H.S., CT 39. Cabell Midland H.S., WV 40. Kelly Walsh H.S., WY 41. Governor Thomas Johnson H.S., MD 42. Eagles H.S., ID 43. Appoquinimink H.S., DE 44. Dover H.S., NH 45. Colony H.S., AK 46. Westbrook H.S., ME 47. (Montana) 48. (North Dakota) 49. (Rhode Island) 50. (Vermont)
|
|
|
Post by ilikeguard on Oct 20, 2023 12:13:19 GMT -6
This was hard. Dissect and interject at will. I didn't spend TOO much time thinking about rankings so feedback is welcomed. Give or take with a +/- 5 placement differential. Montana, North Dakota, Rhode Island or Vermont do not qualify as they either have no marching band programs, or very few, and if they have any at all, they usually aren't competitive. 1. Hebron H.S., TX 2. Carmel H.S., IN 3. Broken Arrow H.S., OK 4. William Mason H.S., OH 5. Tarpon Springs H.S., FL 6. Blue Springs H.S., MO 7. Wando H.S., SC 8. Bentonville H.S., AR 9. Dobyns-Bennett H.S., TN 10. American Fork H.S., UT 11. O'Fallon Township H.S., IL 12. Ayala H.S., CA 13. Rosemount H.S., MN 14. Lincoln H.S., SD 15. Harrison H.S., GA 16. Lafayette H.S., KY 17. Kiski Area H.S., PA 18. Clovis H.S., NM 19. Jenison H.S., MI 20. Hernando H.S., MS 21. Grants Pass H.S., OR 22. Fossil Ridge H.S., CO 23. Dartmouth H.S., MA 24. James Madison H.S., VA 25. Lafayette H.S., LA 26. Green Level H.S., NC 27. Mountain Ridge H.S., AZ 28. Mililani H.S., HI 29. Milard West H.S., NE 30. Sparkman H.S., AL 31. Foothill H.S., NV 32. Blue Valley H.S., KS 33. John P. Stevens H.S., NJ 34. Cicero-North Syracuse H.S., NY 35. Pella H.S., IA 36. Ridgeline H.S., WA 37. Greendale H.S., WI 38. Trumbull H.S., CT 39. Cabell Midland H.S., WV 40. Kelly Walsh H.S., WY 41. Governor Thomas Johnson H.S., MD 42. Eagles H.S., ID 43. Appoquinimink H.S., DE 44. Dover H.S., NH 45. Colony H.S., AK 46. Westbrook H.S., ME 47. (Montana) 48. (North Dakota) 49. (Rhode Island) 50. (Vermont) I don’t think Ayala is the top band in California anymore, but I’m also not certain on who specifically is. I guess we’ll find out in a week!
|
|
|
Post by yayband914 on Oct 20, 2023 12:27:32 GMT -6
This was hard. Dissect and interject at will. I didn't spend TOO much time thinking about rankings so feedback is welcomed. Give or take with a +/- 5 placement differential. Montana, North Dakota, Rhode Island or Vermont do not qualify as they either have no marching band programs, or very few, and if they have any at all, they usually aren't competitive. 1. Hebron H.S., TX 2. Carmel H.S., IN 3. Broken Arrow H.S., OK 4. William Mason H.S., OH 5. Tarpon Springs H.S., FL 6. Blue Springs H.S., MO 7. Wando H.S., SC 8. Bentonville H.S., AR 9. Dobyns-Bennett H.S., TN 10. American Fork H.S., UT 11. O'Fallon Township H.S., IL 12. Ayala H.S., CA 13. Rosemount H.S., MN 14. Lincoln H.S., SD 15. Harrison H.S., GA 16. Lafayette H.S., KY 17. Kiski Area H.S., PA 18. Clovis H.S., NM 19. Jenison H.S., MI 20. Hernando H.S., MS 21. Grants Pass H.S., OR 22. Fossil Ridge H.S., CO 23. Dartmouth H.S., MA 24. James Madison H.S., VA 25. Lafayette H.S., LA 26. Green Level H.S., NC 27. Mountain Ridge H.S., AZ 28. Mililani H.S., HI 29. Milard West H.S., NE 30. Sparkman H.S., AL 31. Foothill H.S., NV 32. Blue Valley H.S., KS 33. John P. Stevens H.S., NJ 34. Cicero-North Syracuse H.S., NY 35. Pella H.S., IA 36. Ridgeline H.S., WA 37. Greendale H.S., WI 38. Trumbull H.S., CT 39. Cabell Midland H.S., WV 40. Kelly Walsh H.S., WY 41. Governor Thomas Johnson H.S., MD 42. Eagles H.S., ID 43. Appoquinimink H.S., DE 44. Dover H.S., NH 45. Colony H.S., AK 46. Westbrook H.S., ME 47. (Montana) 48. (North Dakota) 49. (Rhode Island) 50. (Vermont) I don’t think Ayala is the top band in California anymore, but I’m also not certain on who specifically is. I guess we’ll find out in a week! I was torn between them, Vista Murietta and Chino Hills. There could be someone else I’m not thinking of either!
|
|
|
Post by MarchingBand4Life on Oct 20, 2023 12:29:19 GMT -6
This was hard. Dissect and interject at will. I didn't spend TOO much time thinking about rankings so feedback is welcomed. Give or take with a +/- 5 placement differential. Montana, North Dakota, Rhode Island or Vermont do not qualify as they either have no marching band programs, or very few, and if they have any at all, they usually aren't competitive. . [..] I don’t think Ayala is the top band in California anymore, but I’m also not certain on who specifically is. I guess we’ll find out in a week! Chino Hills?
|
|
|
Post by ilikeguard on Oct 20, 2023 12:42:20 GMT -6
I don’t think Ayala is the top band in California anymore, but I’m also not certain on who specifically is. I guess we’ll find out in a week! I was torn between them, Vista Murietta and Chino Hills. There could be someone else I’m not thinking of either! James Logan and Homestead are also contenders, IMO
|
|
|
Post by statechamp1239 on Mar 2, 2024 23:06:20 GMT -6
Class 1A/2A Nationals:
*I just replaced VT and ND with another Class of the same state*
1. Tarpon Springs, FL - AA 2. Kiski Area, PA - AA 3. Gahr, CA - AA 4. Morton, IL - AA* 5. Jenison, MI - AA 6. Germantown, MS - AA 7. Argyle, TX - AA 8. Choctaw, OK - AA 9. Van Buren Senior, AR - AA 10. Catawba Ridge, SC - AA 11. Grain Valley, MO - AA 12. Bradon Valley, SD - AA 13. Bourbon County, KY - A 14. Dartmouth, MA - AA 15. Pella, IA - A 16. Bellevue West, NE - AA 17. Irondale, MN - AA 18. Marian Catholic, IL - A 19. Green Canyon, UT - AA 20. Buhler, KS - A 21. Mineola, NY - AA 22. Munford, TN - AA 23. Western, IN - A 24. Oak Mountain, AL - AA 25. Ridgeline, WA - A 26. Krum, TX - A* 27. Sherwood, OR - AA 28. Smithfield-Selma, NC - AA 29. E.D. White Catholic, LA - A 30. Kalani, HI - AA 31. Archbishop Carroll, OH - A 32. Loudoun County, VA - AA 33. River Falls, WI - AA 34. George Walton Academy, GA - A 35. Pinecrest Academy Cadence of Nevada, NV - A 36. Norwalk, CT - AA 37. The Classical Academy, CO - A 38. Lovington, NM - AA 39. Liberty, MD - AA 40. Cab Calloway School of the Arts, DE - A 41. Fruitland, ID - A 42. Ironwood Ridge, AZ - AA 43. New Providence, NJ - A 44. Westbrook, ME - A 45. Hurricane, WV - A 46. Dover, NH - AA 47. Portsmouth, RI - AA 48. Havre, MT - A 49. Wheatland, WY - A 50. Colony, AK - AA
|
|
|
Post by ilikeguard on Mar 3, 2024 9:25:26 GMT -6
Class 1A/2A Nationals: *I just replaced VT and ND with another Class of the same state* 1. Tarpon Springs, FL - AA 2. Kiski Area, PA - AA 3. Gahr, CA - AA 4. Morton, IL - AA* 5. Jenison, MI - AA 6. Germantown, MS - AA 7. Choctaw, OK - AA 8. Van Buren Senior, AR - AA 9. Catawba Ridge, SC - AA 10. Grain Valley, MO - AA 11. Bradon Valley, SD - AA 12. Bourbon County, KY - A 13. Dartmouth, MA - AA 14. Pella, IA - A 15. Bellevue West, NE - AA 16. Argyle, TX - AA 17. Irondale, MN - AA 18. Marian Catholic, IL - A 19. Green Canyon, UT - AA 20. Buhler, KS - A 21. Mineola, NY - AA 22. Munford, TN - AA 23. Western, IN - A 24. Oak Mountain, AL - AA 25. Ridgeline, WA - A 26. Krum, TX - A* 27. Sherwood, OR - AA 28. E.D. White Catholic, LA - A 29. Kalani, HI - AA 30. Archbishop Carroll, OH - A 31. Loudoun County, VA - AA 32. River Falls, WI - AA 33. George Walton Academy, GA - A 34. Smithfield-Selma, NC - AA 35. Pinecrest Academy Cadence of Nevada, NV - A 36. Norwalk, CT - AA 37. The Classical Academy, CO - A 38. Lovington, NM - AA 39. Liberty, MD - AA 40. Cab Calloway School of the Arts, DE - A 41. Fruitland, ID - A 42. Ironwood Ridge, AZ - AA 43. New Providence, NJ - A 44. Westbrook, ME - A 45. Hurricane, WV - A 46. Dover, NH - AA 47. Portsmouth, RI - AA 48. Havre, MT - A 49. Wheatland, WY - A 50. Colony, AK - AA You have made a small school fangirl very happy 😊
|
|
|
Post by yayband914 on Mar 3, 2024 9:47:32 GMT -6
Class 1A/2A Nationals: *I just replaced VT and ND with another Class of the same state* 1. Tarpon Springs, FL - AA 2. Kiski Area, PA - AA 3. Gahr, CA - AA 4. Morton, IL - AA* 5. Jenison, MI - AA 6. Germantown, MS - AA 7. Choctaw, OK - AA 8. Van Buren Senior, AR - AA 9. Catawba Ridge, SC - AA 10. Grain Valley, MO - AA 11. Bradon Valley, SD - AA 12. Bourbon County, KY - A 13. Dartmouth, MA - AA 14. Pella, IA - A 15. Bellevue West, NE - AA 16. Argyle, TX - AA 17. Irondale, MN - AA 18. Marian Catholic, IL - A 19. Green Canyon, UT - AA 20. Buhler, KS - A 21. Mineola, NY - AA 22. Munford, TN - AA 23. Western, IN - A 24. Oak Mountain, AL - AA 25. Ridgeline, WA - A 26. Krum, TX - A* 27. Sherwood, OR - AA 28. E.D. White Catholic, LA - A 29. Kalani, HI - AA 30. Archbishop Carroll, OH - A 31. Loudoun County, VA - AA 32. River Falls, WI - AA 33. George Walton Academy, GA - A 34. Smithfield-Selma, NC - AA 35. Pinecrest Academy Cadence of Nevada, NV - A 36. Norwalk, CT - AA 37. The Classical Academy, CO - A 38. Lovington, NM - AA 39. Liberty, MD - AA 40. Cab Calloway School of the Arts, DE - A 41. Fruitland, ID - A 42. Ironwood Ridge, AZ - AA 43. New Providence, NJ - A 44. Westbrook, ME - A 45. Hurricane, WV - A 46. Dover, NH - AA 47. Portsmouth, RI - AA 48. Havre, MT - A 49. Wheatland, WY - A 50. Colony, AK - AA Argyle and Smithfield-Selma that low? Psssshhhhh…
|
|
|
Post by statechamp1239 on Mar 3, 2024 9:54:43 GMT -6
Class 1A/2A Nationals: *I just replaced VT and ND with another Class of the same state* 1. Tarpon Springs, FL - AA ..... 50. Colony, AK - AA Argyle and Smithfield-Selma that low? Psssshhhhh… You know what. Ur right, and when someone right, they are right.
|
|
|
Post by ohioguy2 on Mar 3, 2024 11:11:10 GMT -6
Class 1A/2A Nationals: *I just replaced VT and ND with another Class of the same state* 1. Tarpon Springs, FL - AA 2. Kiski Area, PA - AA 3. Gahr, CA - AA 4. Morton, IL - AA* 5. Jenison, MI - AA 6. Germantown, MS - AA 7. Argyle, TX - AA 8. Choctaw, OK - AA 9. Van Buren Senior, AR - AA 10. Catawba Ridge, SC - AA 11. Grain Valley, MO - AA 12. Bradon Valley, SD - AA 13. Bourbon County, KY - A 14. Dartmouth, MA - AA 15. Pella, IA - A 16. Bellevue West, NE - AA 17. Irondale, MN - AA 18. Marian Catholic, IL - A 19. Green Canyon, UT - AA 20. Buhler, KS - A 21. Mineola, NY - AA 22. Munford, TN - AA 23. Western, IN - A 24. Oak Mountain, AL - AA 25. Ridgeline, WA - A 26. Krum, TX - A* 27. Sherwood, OR - AA 28. Smithfield-Selma, NC - AA 29. E.D. White Catholic, LA - A 30. Kalani, HI - AA 31. Archbishop Carroll, OH - A 32. Loudoun County, VA - AA 33. River Falls, WI - AA 34. George Walton Academy, GA - A 35. Pinecrest Academy Cadence of Nevada, NV - A 36. Norwalk, CT - AA 37. The Classical Academy, CO - A 38. Lovington, NM - AA 39. Liberty, MD - AA 40. Cab Calloway School of the Arts, DE - A 41. Fruitland, ID - A 42. Ironwood Ridge, AZ - AA 43. New Providence, NJ - A 44. Westbrook, ME - A 45. Hurricane, WV - A 46. Dover, NH - AA 47. Portsmouth, RI - AA 48. Havre, MT - A 49. Wheatland, WY - A 50. Colony, AK - AA What was the formula for picking the band for each state here? There are definitely some… bold selections.
|
|
|
Post by statechamp1239 on Mar 3, 2024 11:37:32 GMT -6
What was the formula for picking the band for each state here? There are definitely some… bold selections. I use the formula called my opinion. Where you look at some of the scores, then add by looking at videos, then divide that by low tier madness add that by hair-pulling madness, then multiply all of it by doing this 6 times because you never charge your laptop in time and lose all progress then square root it by a having fun time + boredom, then divide all of it by watching One Piece EggHead, and it equal this crazy list.
|
|
|
Post by statechamp1239 on Mar 3, 2024 13:39:19 GMT -6
Class 1A/2A Nationals: 1. Tarpon Springs, FL - AA ...... 50. Colony, AK - AA What was the formula for picking the band for each state here? There are definitely some… bold selections. Which one do you think is a bold selection? I can probably explain my choice. In my first 3 times I did have Franklin, TN for Class AA to represent TN and Mineola, TX for Class A to represent TX but I completely forgot them around the 4th time I did this. I wanted more Class A so that's why I picked Bourbon County instead of Campbell County which I did have them on my 2-4 times I did this. I could have put Cass, GA for Class AA to represent Georgia, but I wanted to choose a pretty strong Class A for Georgia, George Walton Academy are still amazing they're have less than 20 musicians and the sound they produce is crazy and play so good they have some brave kid.
|
|
|
Post by ohioguy2 on Mar 3, 2024 15:02:22 GMT -6
What was the formula for picking the band for each state here? There are definitely some… bold selections. Which one do you think is a bold selection? I can probably explain my choice. In my first 3 times I did have Franklin, TN for Class AA to represent TN and Mineola, TX for Class A to represent TX but I completely forgot them around the 4th time I did this. I wanted more Class A so that's why I picked Bourbon County instead of Campbell County which I did have them on my 2-4 times I did this. I could have put Cass, GA for Class AA to represent Georgia, but I wanted to choose a pretty strong Class A for Georgia, George Walton Academy are still amazing they're have less than 20 musicians and the sound they produce is crazy and play so good they have some brave kid. You named a few of them. Indiana seemed a bit unique, Western is a great band, but a band like Greenfield-Central has been a consistent semis contender, and a band like Decatur Central has been strong for awhile (even if I have no idea how they’re still AA). Ohio was definitely the one that stood out the most. Carroll had an absolutely fantastic year, but I struggle to find a way to include them on this list. Yes, I know they beat Alter at Obetz, but even if you’re just looking at Class A bands, Alter has been consistently ahead of them. If you’re including AA bands, then you’re looking at Miamisburg, Kings, Worthington Kilbourne, Central Crossing, and others I’m forgetting off the top of my head. If you take just the Ohio bands that attended GN this past year, Carroll placed 9th out of the bands that attended in A and AA and 4th just in Class A. Leaving out a band that just medaled in Class AA this past GN for Arkansas also seemed a little unique to me.
|
|
|
Post by statechamp1239 on Mar 3, 2024 15:49:35 GMT -6
Which one do you think is a bold selection? I can probably explain my choice. In my first 3 times I did have Franklin, TN for Class AA to represent TN and Mineola, TX for Class A to represent TX but I completely forgot them around the 4th time I did this. I wanted more Class A so that's why I picked Bourbon County instead of Campbell County which I did have them on my 2-4 times I did this. I could have put Cass, GA for Class AA to represent Georgia, but I wanted to choose a pretty strong Class A for Georgia, George Walton Academy are still amazing they're have less than 20 musicians and the sound they produce is crazy and play so good they have some brave kid. You named a few of them. Indiana seemed a bit unique, Western is a great band, but a band like Greenfield-Central has been a consistent semis contender, and a band like Decatur Central has been strong for awhile (even if I have no idea how they’re still AA). Ohio was definitely the one that stood out the most. Carroll had an absolutely fantastic year, but I struggle to find a way to include them on this list. Yes, I know they beat Alter at Obetz, but even if you’re just looking at Class A bands, Alter has been consistently ahead of them. If you’re including AA bands, then you’re looking at Miamisburg, Kings, Worthington Kilbourne, Central Crossing, and others I’m forgetting off the top of my head. If you take just the Ohio bands that attended GN this past year, Carroll placed 9th out of the bands that attended in A and AA and 4th just in Class A. Leaving out a band that just medaled in Class AA this past GN for Arkansas also seemed a little unique to me. I already told I wanted more Class A representation, if I just picked the top lead band from Class AA - A from each state the majority of all the list will be dominated by AA bands no given much Class A bands. So, I picked randomly one class for each state, so that's why I picked Western instead of Greenfield-Central and Decatur Central, and that's why I picked Carroll over most of the 2A band who clearly could have beaten them, and New Providence, NJ (A) instead of Elizabeth (AA) or Fort Lee (AA). I like LH show and great job on medaling but doesn't mean I have to pick them I just personally think Van Buren's show is better imo, and they didn't compete in GN, so how would you know what they've have placed on November 9-11 of 2023.
|
|
|
Post by philodemus on Mar 3, 2024 21:33:35 GMT -6
This 1A-2A thing is really interesting, and I honestly can’t imagine how long tracking down and ranking all these relatively obscure groups must have taken. Bravo!
Speaking only of my neck of the woods… not sure Bourbon would be our rep. Even if you get past Campbell in the name of 1A representation, there’s still Beechwood and Murray to consider.
|
|
|
Post by statechamp1239 on Mar 3, 2024 21:53:50 GMT -6
This 1A-2A thing is really interesting, and I honestly can’t imagine how long tracking down and ranking all these relatively obscure groups must have taken. Bravo! Speaking only of my neck of the woods… not sure Bourbon would be our rep. Even if you get past Campbell in the name of 1A representation, there’s still Beechwood and Murray to consider. Don't get me started with Beechwood and Estill County theY definitely underscored at GN
|
|
|
Post by philodemus on Mar 4, 2024 5:40:45 GMT -6
This 1A-2A thing is really interesting, and I honestly can’t imagine how long tracking down and ranking all these relatively obscure groups must have taken. Bravo! Speaking only of my neck of the woods… not sure Bourbon would be our rep. Even if you get past Campbell in the name of 1A representation, there’s still Beechwood and Murray to consider. Don't get me started with Beechwood and Estill County theY definitely underscored at GN Oh no, please do get started! I don’t think this one has been talked about nearly enough.
|
|